Missouri Whitetails - Your Missouri Hunting Resource banner

someone tell me the actual reasoning behind. .

2675 Views 98 Replies 47 Participants Last post by  Freakhunter232
not being able to fill ur firearm anydeer tag with the bow during ML season, but you can during rifle season. this lights a fire under me. as if the other ten terrible season regs didn't already.
81 - 99 of 99 Posts
I think he's looking at the fact that if somebody has shot a buck during the first part of bow season, then shoots a second during rifle season, he has to shoot the third buck during the second half of bow season. During the second half of bow season regardless of what you shoot with a bow, either buck or doe it has to be tagged with your last bow tag and your season is finished.

Am on the same page, or am I way off.
Let me reword what I was thinking

Archery season is closed during regular firearms season----so you have to use your firearms tag on a buck but bow is considered an approved method

ML season you use your leftover firearms tag----if you still have any deer you can shoot a buck with ML and tag it----but because archery season is reopened for ML then you have to use an archery tag on that deer assuming you use bow……

If you want to use a bow during ML season and use your leftover any deer firearm tag, archery season will have to be closed for that period of time that ML is open.

Devils advocate is…..if they close archery season during ML and you shoot a buck during the reg firearms season…..you are pissed off because then late season ML you are out a firearms tag and now cant use that extra any deer archery tag you have because they closed the archery season……so you will never be happy!!!
[rquote=1487220&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487197&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487159&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487093&tid=103863&author=Lungbuster44]JUST SO ITS CLEAR TO EVERYONE WHAT MY QUESTION WAS:

I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY'RE SAYIN BOWSEASON IS OPEN SO USE THOSE TAGS. BUT WHAT IM SAYIN, THAT ITS OK TO USE A LESSOR METHOD ONE DAY THEN NOT THE NEXT. PRETTY CLEAR. AND THERE IS NO ANSWER B/C ITS silly.

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT IT EVEN, NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT HAVIN AN OPPORTUNITY AT 3 BUCKS, IF SOME OF YOU SIMPLETONS WOULD HAVE PAID ATTENTION TO WHAT I HAD SAID EARLIER.

THE ONLY REASON IM UPSET IS THAT IM BETTER WITH A BOW AT 50 YDS THAN A ML, SO IM SCREWED:boohoo::boohoo::boohoo::boohoo:[/rquote]

Evidently I'm on of your so called SIMPLETONS.. Ryan and my post seem to make perfect sense to me..

Let's look at it this way, if ML was set up same as gun and you could shoot a buck with bow and tag it will Firearm tag, what problems would arise from this?

Hmmmmmmmm let's see.. What if during gun season you had shot a buck with your gun or bow, you would have tagged it in with your firearm tag... In this scenario, fortunately for you MDC has made the regs different during ML so you can still shoot a buck with your bow and use bow tags.

IF the rule was not written this way and was the same as gun season you wouldn't be able to bow hunt for a buck during ML because YOUR ANYDEER WAS ALREADY USED DURING REGULAR FIREARMS.

MAYBE A SIMPLETON SHOULD READ THE RESPONSES MORE CAREFULLY.. SEEMS PRETTY BLACK AND WHITE! :shrug: :wave:[/rquote]

you should reconsider your statements they don't make any sense to me. replace your word bow with gun and then you have killed two with a gun. the reg is at least clear enough that only one buck may be harvested with a firearms anydeer tag. lb was talking about an unused firearm any deer tag.

[/rquote]

I'm not sure how to make this any clearer..

If ML and regular firearms had the same regs there would be a problem.

During reg firearmsif you shoot a buck with your bow you have to use your firearm anydeer.

During ML they do not allow you to tag a buck that was bowkilled with your firearms anydeer, you must use your archery anydeer.

OK?

So let's say that during regular firearms season you shot a buck with either your bow or rifle, to tag it you had to use your firearms anydeer. So now you cannot tag another buck with a firearms anydeer because it is used.

If ML was set up the same as regular firearms season, you would not be able to bowkill a buck because you already used your firearms anydeer during rifle season.

Instead MDC says during ML you have to use archery tags for bowkills this way you can still bowhunt for a BUCK. If it wasn't set up this way and someone had shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait..

If this doesn't make sense then you're beyond me.. :D:whiteflag:[/rquote]ditto....looks like you beat me too it :banana-man-yeah:
See less See more
[rquote=1487238&tid=103863&author=ryanlowe02][rquote=1487220&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487197&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487159&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487093&tid=103863&author=Lungbuster44]JUST SO ITS CLEAR TO EVERYONE WHAT MY QUESTION WAS:

I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY'RE SAYIN BOWSEASON IS OPEN SO USE THOSE TAGS. BUT WHAT IM SAYIN, THAT ITS OK TO USE A LESSOR METHOD ONE DAY THEN NOT THE NEXT. PRETTY CLEAR. AND THERE IS NO ANSWER B/C ITS silly.

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT IT EVEN, NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT HAVIN AN OPPORTUNITY AT 3 BUCKS, IF SOME OF YOU SIMPLETONS WOULD HAVE PAID ATTENTION TO WHAT I HAD SAID EARLIER.

THE ONLY REASON IM UPSET IS THAT IM BETTER WITH A BOW AT 50 YDS THAN A ML, SO IM SCREWED:boohoo::boohoo::boohoo::boohoo:[/rquote]

Evidently I'm on of your so called SIMPLETONS.. Ryan and my post seem to make perfect sense to me..

Let's look at it this way, if ML was set up same as gun and you could shoot a buck with bow and tag it will Firearm tag, what problems would arise from this?

Hmmmmmmmm let's see.. What if during gun season you had shot a buck with your gun or bow, you would have tagged it in with your firearm tag... In this scenario, fortunately for you MDC has made the regs different during ML so you can still shoot a buck with your bow and use bow tags.

IF the rule was not written this way and was the same as gun season you wouldn't be able to bow hunt for a buck during ML because YOUR ANYDEER WAS ALREADY USED DURING REGULAR FIREARMS.

MAYBE A SIMPLETON SHOULD READ THE RESPONSES MORE CAREFULLY.. SEEMS PRETTY BLACK AND WHITE! :shrug: :wave:[/rquote]

you should reconsider your statements they don't make any sense to me. replace your word bow with gun and then you have killed two with a gun. the reg is at least clear enough that only one buck may be harvested with a firearms anydeer tag. lb was talking about an unused firearm any deer tag.

[/rquote]

I'm not sure how to make this any clearer..

If ML and regular firearms had the same regs there would be a problem.

During reg firearmsif you shoot a buck with your bow you have to use your firearm anydeer.

During ML they do not allow you to tag a buck that was bowkilled with your firearms anydeer, you must use your archery anydeer.

OK?

So let's say that during regular firearms season you shot a buck with either your bow or rifle, to tag it you had to use your firearms anydeer. So now you cannot tag another buck with a firearms anydeer because it is used.

If ML was set up the same as regular firearms season, you would not be able to bowkill a buck because you already used your firearms anydeer during rifle season.

Instead MDC says during ML you have to use archery tags for bowkills this way you can still bowhunt for a BUCK. If it wasn't set up this way and someone had shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait..

If this doesn't make sense then you're beyond me.. :D:whiteflag:[/rquote]ditto....looks like you beat me too it :banana-man-yeah:[/rquote]

looks like I beat you all and said i reread it for a 3rd time and got the point about the "shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait"..

:banana-man-yeah:
See less See more
Nevermind. Forgot you could doe tag for acrherery.
[rquote=1486972&tid=103863&author=racks-n-beards]It needs to be 1 buck limit period, no matter the method used!!

and able to party hunt on doe tags. That would fix everything!!

:claphands:
[/rquote]

I can only imagine the amount of blasting that would be going on during gun season if party hunting was allowed. Its bad enough as it is. Not to mention the deer that would be killed that there wouldn't be a tag left for.
[rquote=1487240&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487238&tid=103863&author=ryanlowe02][rquote=1487220&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487197&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487159&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487093&tid=103863&author=Lungbuster44]JUST SO ITS CLEAR TO EVERYONE WHAT MY QUESTION WAS:

I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY'RE SAYIN BOWSEASON IS OPEN SO USE THOSE TAGS. BUT WHAT IM SAYIN, THAT ITS OK TO USE A LESSOR METHOD ONE DAY THEN NOT THE NEXT. PRETTY CLEAR. AND THERE IS NO ANSWER B/C ITS silly.

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT IT EVEN, NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT HAVIN AN OPPORTUNITY AT 3 BUCKS, IF SOME OF YOU SIMPLETONS WOULD HAVE PAID ATTENTION TO WHAT I HAD SAID EARLIER.

THE ONLY REASON IM UPSET IS THAT IM BETTER WITH A BOW AT 50 YDS THAN A ML, SO IM SCREWED:boohoo::boohoo::boohoo::boohoo:[/rquote]

Evidently I'm on of your so called SIMPLETONS.. Ryan and my post seem to make perfect sense to me..

Let's look at it this way, if ML was set up same as gun and you could shoot a buck with bow and tag it will Firearm tag, what problems would arise from this?

Hmmmmmmmm let's see.. What if during gun season you had shot a buck with your gun or bow, you would have tagged it in with your firearm tag... In this scenario, fortunately for you MDC has made the regs different during ML so you can still shoot a buck with your bow and use bow tags.

IF the rule was not written this way and was the same as gun season you wouldn't be able to bow hunt for a buck during ML because YOUR ANYDEER WAS ALREADY USED DURING REGULAR FIREARMS.

MAYBE A SIMPLETON SHOULD READ THE RESPONSES MORE CAREFULLY.. SEEMS PRETTY BLACK AND WHITE! :shrug: :wave:[/rquote]

you should reconsider your statements they don't make any sense to me. replace your word bow with gun and then you have killed two with a gun. the reg is at least clear enough that only one buck may be harvested with a firearms anydeer tag. lb was talking about an unused firearm any deer tag.

[/rquote]

I'm not sure how to make this any clearer..

If ML and regular firearms had the same regs there would be a problem.

During reg firearmsif you shoot a buck with your bow you have to use your firearm anydeer.

During ML they do not allow you to tag a buck that was bowkilled with your firearms anydeer, you must use your archery anydeer.

OK?

So let's say that during regular firearms season you shot a buck with either your bow or rifle, to tag it you had to use your firearms anydeer. So now you cannot tag another buck with a firearms anydeer because it is used.

If ML was set up the same as regular firearms season, you would not be able to bowkill a buck because you already used your firearms anydeer during rifle season.

Instead MDC says during ML you have to use archery tags for bowkills this way you can still bowhunt for a BUCK. If it wasn't set up this way and someone had shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait..

If this doesn't make sense then you're beyond me.. :D:whiteflag:[/rquote]ditto....looks like you beat me too it :banana-man-yeah:[/rquote]

looks like I beat you all and said i reread it for a 3rd time and got the point about the "shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait"..

:banana-man-yeah:
[/rquote]

Touche :cheers:
See less See more
[rquote=1487286&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487240&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487238&tid=103863&author=ryanlowe02][rquote=1487220&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487197&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487159&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487093&tid=103863&author=Lungbuster44]JUST SO ITS CLEAR TO EVERYONE WHAT MY QUESTION WAS:

I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY'RE SAYIN BOWSEASON IS OPEN SO USE THOSE TAGS. BUT WHAT IM SAYIN, THAT ITS OK TO USE A LESSOR METHOD ONE DAY THEN NOT THE NEXT. PRETTY CLEAR. AND THERE IS NO ANSWER B/C ITS silly.

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT IT EVEN, NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT HAVIN AN OPPORTUNITY AT 3 BUCKS, IF SOME OF YOU SIMPLETONS WOULD HAVE PAID ATTENTION TO WHAT I HAD SAID EARLIER.

THE ONLY REASON IM UPSET IS THAT IM BETTER WITH A BOW AT 50 YDS THAN A ML, SO IM SCREWED:boohoo::boohoo::boohoo::boohoo:[/rquote]

Evidently I'm on of your so called SIMPLETONS.. Ryan and my post seem to make perfect sense to me..

Let's look at it this way, if ML was set up same as gun and you could shoot a buck with bow and tag it will Firearm tag, what problems would arise from this?

Hmmmmmmmm let's see.. What if during gun season you had shot a buck with your gun or bow, you would have tagged it in with your firearm tag... In this scenario, fortunately for you MDC has made the regs different during ML so you can still shoot a buck with your bow and use bow tags.

IF the rule was not written this way and was the same as gun season you wouldn't be able to bow hunt for a buck during ML because YOUR ANYDEER WAS ALREADY USED DURING REGULAR FIREARMS.

MAYBE A SIMPLETON SHOULD READ THE RESPONSES MORE CAREFULLY.. SEEMS PRETTY BLACK AND WHITE! :shrug: :wave:[/rquote]

you should reconsider your statements they don't make any sense to me. replace your word bow with gun and then you have killed two with a gun. the reg is at least clear enough that only one buck may be harvested with a firearms anydeer tag. lb was talking about an unused firearm any deer tag.

[/rquote]

I'm not sure how to make this any clearer..

If ML and regular firearms had the same regs there would be a problem.

During reg firearmsif you shoot a buck with your bow you have to use your firearm anydeer.

During ML they do not allow you to tag a buck that was bowkilled with your firearms anydeer, you must use your archery anydeer.

OK?

So let's say that during regular firearms season you shot a buck with either your bow or rifle, to tag it you had to use your firearms anydeer. So now you cannot tag another buck with a firearms anydeer because it is used.

If ML was set up the same as regular firearms season, you would not be able to bowkill a buck because you already used your firearms anydeer during rifle season.

Instead MDC says during ML you have to use archery tags for bowkills this way you can still bowhunt for a BUCK. If it wasn't set up this way and someone had shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait..

If this doesn't make sense then you're beyond me.. :D:whiteflag:[/rquote]ditto....looks like you beat me too it :banana-man-yeah:[/rquote]

looks like I beat you all and said i reread it for a 3rd time and got the point about the "shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait"..

:banana-man-yeah:
[/rquote]

Touche :cheers:[/rquote]

I just wanted to quote that mess.

:whistle:
See less See more
[rquote=1487211&tid=103863&author=JackJr]LB after the MDC explains this to you where you finally understand they'll have to either kill you or make you move to California. It all has to do with legal tagging of your deer. Don't want deer shot with rifles and then tagged with a bow tag and so forth. The possiblity of more than one buck with a gun but tagged as archery kill. But as I see it cheaters will cheat no matter the Regs.[/rquote]

haha well i guess all of this discussion has helped me understand it. thanks everyone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! hahhaa but seriously, i guess i understand WHY. now its just that i disagree and that doesnt matter anymore than a fart in the wind. so it sounds like there hasnt been enough huntin pressure and 4wheelers out, so yal got like 11 days!! go get more guns and shoot more deers!!! :whiteflag::whiteflag:
[rquote=1487398&tid=103863&author=racks-n-beards][rquote=1487286&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487240&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487238&tid=103863&author=ryanlowe02][rquote=1487220&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487197&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487159&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487093&tid=103863&author=Lungbuster44]JUST SO ITS CLEAR TO EVERYONE WHAT MY QUESTION WAS:

I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY'RE SAYIN BOWSEASON IS OPEN SO USE THOSE TAGS. BUT WHAT IM SAYIN, THAT ITS OK TO USE A LESSOR METHOD ONE DAY THEN NOT THE NEXT. PRETTY CLEAR. AND THERE IS NO ANSWER B/C ITS silly.

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT IT EVEN, NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT HAVIN AN OPPORTUNITY AT 3 BUCKS, IF SOME OF YOU SIMPLETONS WOULD HAVE PAID ATTENTION TO WHAT I HAD SAID EARLIER.

THE ONLY REASON IM UPSET IS THAT IM BETTER WITH A BOW AT 50 YDS THAN A ML, SO IM SCREWED:boohoo::boohoo::boohoo::boohoo:[/rquote]

Evidently I'm on of your so called SIMPLETONS.. Ryan and my post seem to make perfect sense to me..

Let's look at it this way, if ML was set up same as gun and you could shoot a buck with bow and tag it will Firearm tag, what problems would arise from this?

Hmmmmmmmm let's see.. What if during gun season you had shot a buck with your gun or bow, you would have tagged it in with your firearm tag... In this scenario, fortunately for you MDC has made the regs different during ML so you can still shoot a buck with your bow and use bow tags.

IF the rule was not written this way and was the same as gun season you wouldn't be able to bow hunt for a buck during ML because YOUR ANYDEER WAS ALREADY USED DURING REGULAR FIREARMS.

MAYBE A SIMPLETON SHOULD READ THE RESPONSES MORE CAREFULLY.. SEEMS PRETTY BLACK AND WHITE! :shrug: :wave:[/rquote]

you should reconsider your statements they don't make any sense to me. replace your word bow with gun and then you have killed two with a gun. the reg is at least clear enough that only one buck may be harvested with a firearms anydeer tag. lb was talking about an unused firearm any deer tag.

[/rquote]

I'm not sure how to make this any clearer..

If ML and regular firearms had the same regs there would be a problem.

During reg firearmsif you shoot a buck with your bow you have to use your firearm anydeer.

During ML they do not allow you to tag a buck that was bowkilled with your firearms anydeer, you must use your archery anydeer.

OK?

So let's say that during regular firearms season you shot a buck with either your bow or rifle, to tag it you had to use your firearms anydeer. So now you cannot tag another buck with a firearms anydeer because it is used.

If ML was set up the same as regular firearms season, you would not be able to bowkill a buck because you already used your firearms anydeer during rifle season.

Instead MDC says during ML you have to use archery tags for bowkills this way you can still bowhunt for a BUCK. If it wasn't set up this way and someone had shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait..

If this doesn't make sense then you're beyond me.. :D:whiteflag:[/rquote]ditto....looks like you beat me too it :banana-man-yeah:[/rquote]

looks like I beat you all and said i reread it for a 3rd time and got the point about the "shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait"..

:banana-man-yeah:
[/rquote]

Touche :cheers:[/rquote]

I just wanted to quote that mess.

:whistle:
[/rquote]

:hysterical::hysterical:
See less See more
Nevermind.:D
[rquote=1487636&tid=103863&author=callaojoe][rquote=1487635&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487398&tid=103863&author=racks-n-beards][rquote=1487286&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487240&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487238&tid=103863&author=ryanlowe02][rquote=1487220&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487197&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487159&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487093&tid=103863&author=Lungbuster44]JUST SO ITS CLEAR TO EVERYONE WHAT MY QUESTION WAS:

I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY'RE SAYIN BOWSEASON IS OPEN SO USE THOSE TAGS. BUT WHAT IM SAYIN, THAT ITS OK TO USE A LESSOR METHOD ONE DAY THEN NOT THE NEXT. PRETTY CLEAR. AND THERE IS NO ANSWER B/C ITS silly.

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT IT EVEN, NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT HAVIN AN OPPORTUNITY AT 3 BUCKS, IF SOME OF YOU SIMPLETONS WOULD HAVE PAID ATTENTION TO WHAT I HAD SAID EARLIER.

THE ONLY REASON IM UPSET IS THAT IM BETTER WITH A BOW AT 50 YDS THAN A ML, SO IM SCREWED:boohoo::boohoo::boohoo::boohoo:[/rquote]

Evidently I'm on of your so called SIMPLETONS.. Ryan and my post seem to make perfect sense to me..

Let's look at it this way, if ML was set up same as gun and you could shoot a buck with bow and tag it will Firearm tag, what problems would arise from this?

Hmmmmmmmm let's see.. What if during gun season you had shot a buck with your gun or bow, you would have tagged it in with your firearm tag... In this scenario, fortunately for you MDC has made the regs different during ML so you can still shoot a buck with your bow and use bow tags.

IF the rule was not written this way and was the same as gun season you wouldn't be able to bow hunt for a buck during ML because YOUR ANYDEER WAS ALREADY USED DURING REGULAR FIREARMS.

MAYBE A SIMPLETON SHOULD READ THE RESPONSES MORE CAREFULLY.. SEEMS PRETTY BLACK AND WHITE! :shrug: :wave:[/rquote]

you should reconsider your statements they don't make any sense to me. replace your word bow with gun and then you have killed two with a gun. the reg is at least clear enough that only one buck may be harvested with a firearms anydeer tag. lb was talking about an unused firearm any deer tag.

[/rquote]

I'm not sure how to make this any clearer..

If ML and regular firearms had the same regs there would be a problem.

During reg firearmsif you shoot a buck with your bow you have to use your firearm anydeer.

During ML they do not allow you to tag a buck that was bowkilled with your firearms anydeer, you must use your archery anydeer.

OK?

So let's say that during regular firearms season you shot a buck with either your bow or rifle, to tag it you had to use your firearms anydeer. So now you cannot tag another buck with a firearms anydeer because it is used.

If ML was set up the same as regular firearms season, you would not be able to bowkill a buck because you already used your firearms anydeer during rifle season.

Instead MDC says during ML you have to use archery tags for bowkills this way you can still bowhunt for a BUCK. If it wasn't set up this way and someone had shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait..

If this doesn't make sense then you're beyond me.. :D:whiteflag:[/rquote]ditto....looks like you beat me too it :banana-man-yeah:[/rquote]

looks like I beat you all and said i reread it for a 3rd time and got the point about the "shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait"..

:banana-man-yeah:
[/rquote]

Touche :cheers:[/rquote]

I just wanted to quote that mess.

:whistle:
[/rquote]

:hysterical::hysterical: [/rquote]

Cool.:D[/rquote]

I felt left out:goodnight:
See less See more
[rquote=1487697&tid=103863&author=DCL][rquote=1487636&tid=103863&author=callaojoe][rquote=1487635&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487398&tid=103863&author=racks-n-beards][rquote=1487286&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487240&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487238&tid=103863&author=ryanlowe02][rquote=1487220&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487197&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487159&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487093&tid=103863&author=Lungbuster44]JUST SO ITS CLEAR TO EVERYONE WHAT MY QUESTION WAS:

I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY'RE SAYIN BOWSEASON IS OPEN SO USE THOSE TAGS. BUT WHAT IM SAYIN, THAT ITS OK TO USE A LESSOR METHOD ONE DAY THEN NOT THE NEXT. PRETTY CLEAR. AND THERE IS NO ANSWER B/C ITS silly.

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT IT EVEN, NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT HAVIN AN OPPORTUNITY AT 3 BUCKS, IF SOME OF YOU SIMPLETONS WOULD HAVE PAID ATTENTION TO WHAT I HAD SAID EARLIER.

THE ONLY REASON IM UPSET IS THAT IM BETTER WITH A BOW AT 50 YDS THAN A ML, SO IM SCREWED:boohoo::boohoo::boohoo::boohoo:[/rquote]

Evidently I'm on of your so called SIMPLETONS.. Ryan and my post seem to make perfect sense to me..

Let's look at it this way, if ML was set up same as gun and you could shoot a buck with bow and tag it will Firearm tag, what problems would arise from this?

Hmmmmmmmm let's see.. What if during gun season you had shot a buck with your gun or bow, you would have tagged it in with your firearm tag... In this scenario, fortunately for you MDC has made the regs different during ML so you can still shoot a buck with your bow and use bow tags.

IF the rule was not written this way and was the same as gun season you wouldn't be able to bow hunt for a buck during ML because YOUR ANYDEER WAS ALREADY USED DURING REGULAR FIREARMS.

MAYBE A SIMPLETON SHOULD READ THE RESPONSES MORE CAREFULLY.. SEEMS PRETTY BLACK AND WHITE! :shrug: :wave:[/rquote]

you should reconsider your statements they don't make any sense to me. replace your word bow with gun and then you have killed two with a gun. the reg is at least clear enough that only one buck may be harvested with a firearms anydeer tag. lb was talking about an unused firearm any deer tag.

[/rquote]

I'm not sure how to make this any clearer..

If ML and regular firearms had the same regs there would be a problem.

During reg firearmsif you shoot a buck with your bow you have to use your firearm anydeer.

During ML they do not allow you to tag a buck that was bowkilled with your firearms anydeer, you must use your archery anydeer.

OK?

So let's say that during regular firearms season you shot a buck with either your bow or rifle, to tag it you had to use your firearms anydeer. So now you cannot tag another buck with a firearms anydeer because it is used.

If ML was set up the same as regular firearms season, you would not be able to bowkill a buck because you already used your firearms anydeer during rifle season.

Instead MDC says during ML you have to use archery tags for bowkills this way you can still bowhunt for a BUCK. If it wasn't set up this way and someone had shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait..

If this doesn't make sense then you're beyond me.. :D:whiteflag:[/rquote]ditto....looks like you beat me too it :banana-man-yeah:[/rquote]

looks like I beat you all and said i reread it for a 3rd time and got the point about the "shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait"..

:banana-man-yeah:
[/rquote]

Touche :cheers:[/rquote]

I just wanted to quote that mess.

:whistle:
[/rquote]

:hysterical::hysterical: [/rquote]

Cool.:D[/rquote]

I felt left out:goodnight:[/rquote]
See less See more
[rquote=1487703&tid=103863&author=mathewsshooter89][rquote=1487697&tid=103863&author=DCL][rquote=1487636&tid=103863&author=callaojoe][rquote=1487635&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487398&tid=103863&author=racks-n-beards][rquote=1487286&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487240&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487238&tid=103863&author=ryanlowe02][rquote=1487220&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487197&tid=103863&author=20 feet high][rquote=1487159&tid=103863&author=Tuffke][rquote=1487093&tid=103863&author=Lungbuster44]JUST SO ITS CLEAR TO EVERYONE WHAT MY QUESTION WAS:

I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY'RE SAYIN BOWSEASON IS OPEN SO USE THOSE TAGS. BUT WHAT IM SAYIN, THAT ITS OK TO USE A LESSOR METHOD ONE DAY THEN NOT THE NEXT. PRETTY CLEAR. AND THERE IS NO ANSWER B/C ITS silly.

NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT IT EVEN, NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT HAVIN AN OPPORTUNITY AT 3 BUCKS, IF SOME OF YOU SIMPLETONS WOULD HAVE PAID ATTENTION TO WHAT I HAD SAID EARLIER.

THE ONLY REASON IM UPSET IS THAT IM BETTER WITH A BOW AT 50 YDS THAN A ML, SO IM SCREWED:boohoo::boohoo::boohoo::boohoo:[/rquote]

Evidently I'm on of your so called SIMPLETONS.. Ryan and my post seem to make perfect sense to me..

Let's look at it this way, if ML was set up same as gun and you could shoot a buck with bow and tag it will Firearm tag, what problems would arise from this?

Hmmmmmmmm let's see.. What if during gun season you had shot a buck with your gun or bow, you would have tagged it in with your firearm tag... In this scenario, fortunately for you MDC has made the regs different during ML so you can still shoot a buck with your bow and use bow tags.

IF the rule was not written this way and was the same as gun season you wouldn't be able to bow hunt for a buck during ML because YOUR ANYDEER WAS ALREADY USED DURING REGULAR FIREARMS.

MAYBE A SIMPLETON SHOULD READ THE RESPONSES MORE CAREFULLY.. SEEMS PRETTY BLACK AND WHITE! :shrug: :wave:[/rquote]

you should reconsider your statements they don't make any sense to me. replace your word bow with gun and then you have killed two with a gun. the reg is at least clear enough that only one buck may be harvested with a firearms anydeer tag. lb was talking about an unused firearm any deer tag.

[/rquote]

I'm not sure how to make this any clearer..

If ML and regular firearms had the same regs there would be a problem.

During reg firearmsif you shoot a buck with your bow you have to use your firearm anydeer.

During ML they do not allow you to tag a buck that was bowkilled with your firearms anydeer, you must use your archery anydeer.

OK?

So let's say that during regular firearms season you shot a buck with either your bow or rifle, to tag it you had to use your firearms anydeer. So now you cannot tag another buck with a firearms anydeer because it is used.

If ML was set up the same as regular firearms season, you would not be able to bowkill a buck because you already used your firearms anydeer during rifle season.

Instead MDC says during ML you have to use archery tags for bowkills this way you can still bowhunt for a BUCK. If it wasn't set up this way and someone had shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait..

If this doesn't make sense then you're beyond me.. :D:whiteflag:[/rquote]ditto....looks like you beat me too it :banana-man-yeah:[/rquote]

looks like I beat you all and said i reread it for a 3rd time and got the point about the "shot a buck during rifle they would not be able to bowhunt for a buck during ML, they would just have to wait"..

:banana-man-yeah:
[/rquote]

Touche :cheers:[/rquote]

I just wanted to quote that mess.

:whistle:
[/rquote]

:hysterical::hysterical: [/rquote]

Cool.:D[/rquote]

I felt left out:goodnight:[/rquote]
[/rquote]

:cheers:
:cheers:
:cheers:
See less See more
This topic should be closed due to excessive repetition.
If someone else has already answered this I'm sorry for repetition.

The reason you can't bowhunt on a firearms tag during muzzleloader season is as mentioned before,,bow season is closed during firearms season and is opened during ML season. The regulations allow you to carry more than one weapon if you choose as long as they qualify as a legal method. But you are not allowed to carry a firearm during bowseason if you are bowhunting. The only way to avoid confusion over who is bowhunting and who is ML hunting is to not allow a bow as a legal weapon for someone with a muzzleloader tag. It makes sense even if it is as clear as mud.

:cheers::cheers:
still say all bout the revenue, buy buy buy, the get ya comin and goin
I agree LB44 after this rifle season i have offically swore off the rifle for good. Bow from now on. :claphands:
81 - 99 of 99 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top