I have only been been hunting for 5 years, thus the novicehunter designation. Here's my two centavos worth from my limited experience. If I am doing stationary hunting from a stand, I want a scope for precised and calculated target acquisition. If I am walking, stalking, or doing a drive, I want a peepsite for fast but accurate target acquisition.
I shot a big doe this year that I had jumped up, she stopped for a half second to look back at me to see if I was really a threat. When turned back to take off running, I shot her with the 30-30 equipped with a peepsite. I would have never aquired that target fast enough to make that shot with my scoped gun.
So, the question must be asked, what type of hunting are you going to do? Sitting or Moving? If you are going to do both, you may need two guns as I have.