Missouri Whitetails - Your Missouri Hunting Resource banner

basic question about "silver"guns

1374 Views 12 Replies 8 Participants Last post by  67Firebird
I'll be honest,I have no clue.
I'm starting to get a few handguns,inexpensive utility types.Some are silver.
I hear/read stainless steel,nickle plated,chrome plated,steel,alloy,etc...zinc?

Anyway,I can look them all up individually,just looking for a starting point.
How can I tell what is what,and if it makes a difference.
Other than S.S. being better for humid/saltwater condition

For an example,I mentioned in the other thread I have a high standard 22 mag derringer,silver with fake pearl grips,very pretty,but not super shiny.
Have a few older s&w 38 longs still in decent shape,duller but no rust.

Not even sure what I'm asking,just looking for comments.

I'm guessing somewhere a magnet will be mentioned.
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
If a magnet doesn’t stick they are aluminum. :D
  • Like
Reactions: 2
The easy answer is that if they're plated, it will wear off over time.

I prefer brushed stainless. Here's my daily carry, a Taurus 85 .38spl
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
so brushed stainless isanother catagory?
I'll disagree with 67Firebird. Stainless steel, as a metal, is relatively "soft" and the finish scratches easily. Frankly, I'd rather have a blued gun than a stainless one, this is based on experience with a LOT of both types of finishes.
For me, there's only one finish beyond blue, that is taking a blued gun and having it hard-chromed (various trade names like Armalloy, Metalloy, and others). I've had stainless guns that scratched easily, but I had a 1911 competition gun hard-chromed (that gun got shot a LOT over the years, enough that the frame cracked after 20+ years of hard shooting). Even after the frame cracked, the gun still looked like new, and it had been dragged out of numerous holsters over the years. Before I got it hard-chromed, I'd worn the blue clean off the gun, and had even changed the dimensions on the slide from the drag on suede-lined holsters.
If I were to buy another 1911 for such purposes, I'd get the thing hard-chromed, even if it were stainless. I've scratched the finishes off numerous Rugers and Smith and Wessons, (the Smiths were the worst, by far, they scratched like a sonuvagun). I also worked at an indoor shooting range/gun shop for awhile, and saw all manner of guns coming into the place. Usually, the stainless guns looked like they'd been dragged down the road behind a pickup, even if the owner was careful. The Second Generation Smith autos were the worst, but the Third Generation guns would scratch up, too. Smith revolvers generally kept a good appearance if they were owned by a civilian, but the cops let their guns go to Hell, and most police trade-ins looked like crap (we sold a lot of those, one of our suppliers was a police distributor who took in the revolvers when the cops went to SIGs or Glocks.
See less See more
so brushed stainless isanother catagory?
Yes, and I think it's better than polished stainless. The smoother the finish, the easier it is to mess it up. That's one of the reasons I don't care too much for blued guns anymore, and the same for having wood stocks/grips.
Not all stainless firearms are created equal. When I was working the shooting range for the scouts years ago we had a bunch of stainless marlin bolt actions that started rusting after the first year. I personally have had three Ruger all weather rifles that have been through hell and back and look as good as ever. On the finishes I prefer the semi gloss smooth all weathers from years ago. I find the smoother the finish the less places for moisture to hold onto.
Imperfections are character. And I enjoy them actually. Makes it your own imo.

To a certain extent obviously, If I wanted it perfect I'd just keep it in the safe.

Can't wait til I finally scratch this guy. Lol

Wood Font Everyday carry Gun barrel Metal
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
5
Here's the holster wear on my Bearcat, that I bought new in 2017.
Bicycle part Material property Cylinder Font Carbon


Here's the chrome wear on my High Standard Double Nine. Not sure how old it is; it belonged to my former father-in-law.
Revolver Finger Personal protective equipment Gun accessory Bullet


Bicycle part Finger Auto part Composite material Nickel


Here's my brushed stainless Taurus 85, that I bought used earlier this year. A couple small scratches, but no wear.

Revolver Air gun Trigger Yellow Everyday carry


Yellow Revolver Font Computer keyboard Gun accessory
See less See more
That wear on the Double Nine is typical of "nickeled" revolvers, but "hard chrome" is harder than Chinese arithmetic. That's why it's so popular amongst IPSC shooters. Personally, I think blue wear adds character, it shows you're using the gun, instead of owning a safe queen.

There's another finish (actually, a lot of other finishes) that I like quite a bit, parkerizing. It's pretty doggoned good, too, and holds up well to hard use, which is why the military uses it so much. All those old GI guns that have shown up over the years prove it's worth.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Imperfections are character. And I enjoy them actually. Makes it your own imo.

To a certain extent obviously, If I wanted it perfect I'd just keep it in the safe.

Can't wait til I finally scratch this guy. Lol

View attachment 145521
You keep dropping it in the rocks and it won't be long.
Personally, I think blue wear adds character, it shows you're using the gun, instead of owning a safe queen.

There's another finish (actually, a lot of other finishes) that I like quite a bit, parkerizing.
I agree with both of those, but still generally shy away from blued guns now.
Parkerizing looks great, and so does Cerakote (like the new Wranglers).
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top